A developer is deciding the best method for storing theme

Comparing Methods for Storing Theme in Web Applications

Alireza Keshavarz Shirazi

Alireza Keshavarz Shirazi

May 11, 2023

Picture this: You're building a sleek web application with a user-friendly interface. Now, imagine your users have the option to choose their preferred theme—dark mode for those late-night coding sessions, perhaps? But how do you ensure their theme choice sticks around, even when they close the browser or switch devices? Fear not! In this article, I'll explore three nifty methods for storing theme preferences in your web applications. From the trusty Context API to the ever-reliable localStorage, I'll weigh the pros and cons of each approach, helping you find the perfect fit for your next project. So, grab a cup of coffee (or tea, if that's your thing) and let's dive in!

Context API:

The Context API in React allows you to manage global state and share data across components without having to pass props manually at every level. You can create a context for the theme and provide it at the top level of your component tree. Components can then access the theme state and update it using the useContext hook.

Tradeoffs:

While convenient for managing global state, the Context API may lead to unnecessary re-renders if the context provider is re-rendered frequently. It can also be overkill for small applications, as it introduces additional complexity compared to simpler solutions like localStorage.

Session Variable:

Session storage allows you to store data for a particular session, which persists as long as the browser tab is open. You can store the theme preference in the session storage and retrieve it when needed.

Tradeoffs:

The theme preference is only stored for the duration of the session. If the user closes the tab or the browser, the preference is lost. It's not suitable for scenarios where you want to persist the theme preference across sessions or if the user expects their preference to persist even after closing the browser.

localStorage:

localStorage provides a way to store key-value pairs in the browser with no expiration date. You can save the theme preference in localStorage and retrieve it whenever the application loads.

Tradeoffs:

While localStorage provides persistence across browser sessions, it's not scoped to a particular tab or window like session storage. Overuse of localStorage can lead to performance issues, especially on older browsers or devices with limited storage capacity. There are security considerations with localStorage, as it's accessible to any script running in the same domain. It's not suitable for storing sensitive information.

Choosing the Right Method:

For simple applications where persistence across sessions or tabs isn't necessary, using context with useContext might be the simplest and most efficient solution. If you need persistence within a session but don't want the preference to persist across browser sessions, session storage can be a good option. If you require persistence across browser sessions and tabs, localStorage is the way to go, but be mindful of its limitations and security considerations. Ultimately, the choice depends on the specific requirements and constraints of your application.

Want to read more?

AWS Summit Amsterdam 2024-Unleashing Inn. . .

April 11, 2024

AWS-Summit-Amsterdam-2024

Everything a Web Developer Should Know A. . .

December 6, 2022

Happy developer with figma background

Harnessing the Power of useContext, useM. . .

September 13, 2022

A hook around react logo on the seaside

Using Context API or Redux (Unbiased Per. . .

July 23, 2021

A gray pitbull relaxing on the sidewalk with its tongue hanging out

Why It's Time to Ditch Redux in React: E. . .

June 15, 2021

redux is not dead, but ...